New York e-cig tax bill draws veto push as Hochul weighs 20% wholesale rate
New York's legislature passed a bill moving the e-cigarette tax from 20% retail to 20% wholesale. The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids wants a veto; convenience stores want Hochul to sign.
Key points
- New York's legislature passed a bill replacing a 20% retail e-cigarette tax with a 20% wholesale tax.
- The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids says a 20% wholesale rate cuts the effective tax by more than half and wants a veto.
- The group says a wholesale rate of about 48% would keep the tax level unchanged.
- The Association of Convenience Stores says the bill does not lower taxes and urges Hochul to sign it.
- The bill carries an immediate effective date, which critics say complicates amendments.
On this page
- Sponsor says the bill strengthens enforcement of the state’s flavoured vape ban
- Critics say a 20% wholesale rate cuts the effective tax by more than half
- Two rate structures compared
- Convenience stores back the bill and dispute the price claim
- An immediate effective date narrows the room for amendments
- What changes for distributors and importers
- Questions readers ask
New York’s e-cigarette tax would move from the retail counter to the wholesale level at the same 20% rate under a bill that has passed both chambers and now sits with Gov. Kathy Hochul, who faces calls to veto it.
Sponsor says the bill strengthens enforcement of the state’s flavoured vape ban
Democratic state Sen. Leroy Comrie says his Senate bill is intended to tighten enforcement of New York’s ban on flavoured vapour products, which took effect in 2020. The minimum purchase age under that ban is 21.
Comrie said the aim is a better tracking process that does not put the burden on small businesses, and that work on limiting vapour product distribution has run for four years. He described the tax-structure objection as a technicality that can be corrected with the governor’s office.
Critics say a 20% wholesale rate cuts the effective tax by more than half
The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids supports shifting collection to wholesale but opposes the rate and the enforcement language, according to Kevin O’Flaherty, its associate vice president for state and local policy.
O’Flaherty said wholesale prices are generally less than half of retail prices, so swapping a 20% retail tax for a 20% wholesale tax cuts the tax by more than half. He said keeping the tax level while changing the collection point would require a wholesale rate of about 48%.
He also said the administration and the Department of Taxation and Finance have concluded the bill’s language does not give them the tools to enforce the tax as intended.
Two rate structures compared
| Structure | Tax base | Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Current law | Retail sale | 20% |
| Bill as passed | Wholesale | 20% |
| Rate the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids says would hold the tax level | Wholesale | About 48% |
VapeBrief’s calculation: if wholesale prices are less than half of retail prices, as O’Flaherty states, a 20% wholesale rate collects less than half the cash a 20% retail rate collects on the same product.
Convenience stores back the bill and dispute the price claim
Alison Ritchie, president of the Association of Convenience Stores, said in a statement to Spectrum News 1 that the bill does not lower taxes or make nicotine products cheaper. She said it moves collection to the appropriate point in the distribution chain so the state can identify and hold violators accountable.
Ritchie said the measure would give New York tools against distributors of illegal, unregulated vapour products and urged Hochul to sign it. The association’s position conflicts with the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids on whether the bill makes products cheaper; neither side has published its own price data in the material available.
An immediate effective date narrows the room for amendments
O’Flaherty said fixing the enforcement language through amendments would be challenging because the bill carries an immediate effective date. The campaign wants Hochul to veto the bill and instead propose the same changes in her upcoming budget.
The bill has passed both houses but has not been signed. Hochul has said she is considering it, and no signature deadline or effective date has been stated.
What changes for distributors and importers
Analysis: a shift to wholesale collection would put the tax point at the distributor or wholesaler rather than the shop counter, so New York-facing sellers would need wholesale invoice records that support the rate applied. The enforcement dispute between the taxation department and the bill’s supporters suggests the practical paperwork requirements are unresolved while the bill awaits a decision.
Hochul’s choice is the next step: sign, veto, or leave the bill to be reworked in her budget proposal.
Questions readers ask
Would the bill lower the tax on e-cigarettes in New York?
The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids says yes, because 20% of a wholesale price is less than 20% of a retail price and wholesale prices are generally under half of retail. The Association of Convenience Stores says no, stating the bill does not lower taxes and only moves collection along the distribution chain.
Has Gov. Kathy Hochul signed the bill?
No. The bill passed both houses of the legislature and Hochul has said she is considering it, according to the reporting. The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids is asking her to veto it.
18+ only. This site is for adult readers and provides news and information only. It is not medical, legal or purchase advice. Nicotine is addictive. Always check the official text of any regulation in your market. Health Information



