Skip to content
Sunday, November 22, 2026
Latest
Industry Australia Denmark

Tobacco Control paper flags PMI complaints against researchers

A paper in Tobacco Control, led by Emily Banks, describes complaints to employers, FoI requests and legal threats as a systemic pushback strategy against tobacco and vaping researchers. It cites a PMI Denmark complaint against Charlotta Pisinger.

Eppendorf automatic pipettes on a stand. The picture was taken at XLAB Experimental Laboratory, Göttingen, Germany
Eppendorf automatic pipettes on a stand. The picture was taken at XLAB Experimental Laboratory, Göttingen, Germany. Photographed 2012-08-15. File photo: Thctamm / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0. Image: Thctamm Image source · CC BY-SA 3.0 · Display crop and size variants; source image content retained.

Key points

  • A Tobacco Control paper published on 19 November, led by Prof Emily Banks, says complaints, freedom of information requests and legal threats form a systemic pushback strategy against tobacco control researchers.
  • The Danish subsidiary of Philip Morris International filed a complaint accusing Prof Charlotta Pisinger of breaching University of Southern Denmark research communication standards in media interviews.
  • PMI's Danish corporate affairs manager said the company respects academics' right to express critical views and that the complaint does not seek to restrict Pisinger's freedom to speak.
  • The paper calls on employers to support staff through complaints and on governments to enforce rules barring tobacco industry interference in health policy more strictly.
  • Lotus Sofie Bast said she counted about 15 tobacco, nicotine and e-cigarette industry representatives at a youth nicotine data launch after the industry fought to attend.
On this page
  1. PMI’s Danish unit filed a complaint against a researcher’s employer
  2. The paper describes intimidation as an occupational health and safety issue
  3. Co-authors describe abuse after speaking about vaping and nicotine
  4. Early-career researchers face the heaviest deterrent
  5. What the findings mean for companies in the nicotine supply chain
  6. Questions readers ask

A paper published in Tobacco Control on 19 November describes complaints to researchers’ employers, freedom of information requests and legal threats as a systemic pushback strategy against tobacco control advocates, and cites a Philip Morris International complaint against a Danish public health professor.

PMI’s Danish unit filed a complaint against a researcher’s employer

Prof Charlotta Pisinger, a medical doctor and public health researcher, said a complaint from the Danish subsidiary of Philip Morris International arrived while she was being interviewed. The company accused her of breaching the University of Southern Denmark’s research communication standards in media interviews where she questioned the safety of heated tobacco and vapes and PMI’s health intentions.

The complaint stated that Pisinger claims PMI lies and deceives, and said the company assumed her statements were polemical rather than an expression of a factual legal matter. It also accused her of not clarifying whether her comments reflected scientific expertise or personal opinion, of overstating conclusions and of omitting context.

A PMI corporate affairs manager in Denmark said the company respects academics’ right to express views critical of it, according to the article, and that claims presented as scientific fact should be open to scrutiny. The manager said the complaint does not seek to restrict Pisinger’s freedom to speak or take part in public debate.

The paper describes intimidation as an occupational health and safety issue

The study, led by the Australian physician and epidemiologist Prof Emily Banks, characterises complaints to employers as part of a systemic challenge rather than isolated incidents. It accuses the tobacco industry of a deliberate strategy to silence critics, distort evidence and weaken regulation.

The authors say it is not possible to establish tobacco industry involvement with certainty in every case of intimidation. The paper calls on employers to support staff through complaints and on governments to enforce rules barring industry interference in health policy more strictly. It also recommends risk management plans, stronger digital security and documenting and reporting threats.

Tactic named in the paper Example cited Target
Complaint to employer PMI Denmark complaint to University of Southern Denmark Prof Charlotta Pisinger
Online discreditation Researchers labelled zealots and extremists Tobacco researchers generally
Freedom of information requests Denmark institute legal department spends hours responding National Institute of Public Health
Attendance at events About 15 industry representatives at a youth nicotine data launch Lotus Sofie Bast’s institute

Co-authors describe abuse after speaking about vaping and nicotine

Raglan Maddox, an associate professor at the Australian National University and a co-author, said the most abuse he received in one day followed public comments on children’s health during a vaping inquiry. He described children grappling with nicotine addiction and said the abuse questioned his appearance and character rather than the industry.

Maddox also criticised an Australian parliamentary inquiry into illicit tobacco, where public health experts testified publicly while tobacco industry figures gave evidence behind closed doors and anonymously.

Banks said freedom of information requests can be weaponised for industry intimidation, while acknowledging that people have a right to seek information. The paper says pushback has escalated to physical violence in countries where advocates have little institutional or government backing, and that death threats have occurred, though rarely.

Early-career researchers face the heaviest deterrent

Lotus Sofie Bast, from Denmark’s National Institute of Public Health, said she worries the industry’s conduct deters young researchers from entering the field. She said she and her legal department spend hours answering industry freedom of information requests, and that industry representatives have attended student PhD defences taking notes and wearing sunglasses indoors.

At an event launching youth nicotine data, Bast counted about 15 tobacco, nicotine and e-cigarette industry representatives in the room after the industry fought to attend. Pisinger said a tobacco company demanded she be fired from a hospital where she worked in 2013, and that each complaint requires her to explain herself and provide documentation, which she called time-consuming and unpleasant.

The paper cites the World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, which requires governments to protect health policies from tobacco industry influence.

What the findings mean for companies in the nicotine supply chain

Analysis: the paper’s focus on third parties and front groups means manufacturers and distributors with tobacco-company ownership or backing could face more scrutiny of how their submissions, consultations and information requests are received by health bodies. Researchers are asking employers and governments to treat pushback as an occupational safety matter, which increases the documentation burden on any company engaging with public health institutions.

Questions readers ask

What did Philip Morris International's Danish subsidiary complain about?

It accused Prof Charlotta Pisinger of breaching the University of Southern Denmark's research communication standards in media interviews where she questioned the safety of heated tobacco and vapes and PMI's health intentions, according to the article.

What does the paper recommend for employers and governments?

Employers should support staff through complaints, and governments should enforce rules barring tobacco industry interference in health policy more strictly, the paper says.

Share

Sources

18+ only. This site is for adult readers and provides news and information only. It is not medical, legal or purchase advice. Nicotine is addictive. Always check the official text of any regulation in your market. Health Information

Dylan Harper

Dylan Harper covers the vape industry and market trends for VapeBrief. He previously spent seven years in consumer-goods market research.

About this byline →

Daily Brief newsletter

A concise email at 08:00 U.S. Eastern time each day, with links to the previous day’s published briefs.

Topics of interest

Active immediately, no confirmation click needed. Every email includes an unsubscribe link. See our Privacy Policy.