Skip to content
Sunday, November 22, 2026
Latest
Regulation Indonesia

Indonesia court presses government on full vape ban

Constitutional Court judge Saldi Isra asked Indonesia's government how it would control conventional cigarettes if it bans vapes, during a 17 November hearing on a petition to prohibit e-cigarette production, imports, distribution and use.

E-Puffer XPOD disposable electronic cigarette using nicotine salts.
E-Puffer XPOD disposable electronic cigarette using nicotine salts. Photographed 2018-10-29. File photo: Vaping360 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0. Image: Vaping360 Image source · CC BY 2.0 · Display crop and size variants; source image content retained.

Key points

  • Constitutional Court judge Saldi Isra asked the government on 17 November 2026 how it would control conventional cigarettes if e-cigarettes are banned.
  • National Police circular SE/9/X/2026 of 30 October 2026 bans e-cigarette use by police personnel, and MUI Fatwa No. 131 of 2026 of 6 November 2026 declares it haram.
  • The next hearing in case No. 363/PUU-XXIV/2026 is set for 25 November 2026.
On this page
  1. Judges want a rule that does not stop at vapes
  2. The government points to a 98 percent lab finding
  3. Two institutions have already restricted vaping
  4. Industry faces a decision that could go beyond control to prohibition
  5. The next hearing is on 25 November
  6. Questions readers ask

Indonesia’s government must explain how it would tighten control of conventional cigarettes if e-cigarettes are banned, a Constitutional Court judge said at a 17 November hearing.

Judge Saldi Isra put the question to the government’s representative during review of Law No. 17 of 2023 on Health, case No. 363/PUU-XXIV/2026, according to IDN Times and Media Indonesia. The petitioners want production, imports, distribution and use of e-cigarettes prohibited.

Judges want a rule that does not stop at vapes

Saldi argued that conventional cigarettes also face public opposition, so a ban on the non-conventional product needs a matching stance on the conventional one. Media Indonesia quoted him saying that if non-conventional cigarettes are banned, conventional cigarettes must be tightened too.

He also recalled how tobacco provisions appeared and disappeared during earlier health legislation, and said business interests played a part in that. The court has not ruled on the petition; the 17 November session was an evidence hearing.

The government points to a 98 percent lab finding

Health Ministry secretary-general Kunta Wibawa Dasa Nugraha told the court that e-cigarettes are no longer only a nicotine-risk question, describing them as a drug-abuse problem too.

The ministry noted that etomidate, an anaesthetic, was classified as a Group II narcotic under Health Ministerial Regulation No. 15 of 2025. Kunta said refillable liquids, varied device designs and replaceable liquid compositions let others disguise the movement of harmful substances.

Measure cited by the government Figure
Testing period January 2025 to September 2026
Samples positive for narcotics, psychotropics or NPS 98 percent

Two institutions have already restricted vaping

National Police Chief circular SE/9/X/2026, issued on 30 October 2026, bans e-cigarette use by all police personnel, at work and outside it, according to the government’s submission.

The Indonesian Ulema Council set Fatwa No. 131 of 2026 on 6 November 2026, declaring e-cigarette use haram on health, environmental and drug-diversion grounds. The council’s reasoning is a religious ruling, not a regulatory decision by the state.

Saldi separately raised the environmental argument often used for switching, namely the absence of cigarette butts, and said health remains a separate matter.

Industry faces a decision that could go beyond control to prohibition

The government told the court that the existing control framework under Law 17/2023 reflects constitutional authority and should be judged on that basis, but that later risk findings could justify tighter restrictions or a full ban.

Manufacturers, exporters and distributors supplying Indonesia therefore cannot yet plan against a fixed rule. Compliance work, registration and shipment timing depend on how the court treats the current control provisions, and on whether the government’s stated willingness to move toward prohibition becomes policy. That reading is VapeBrief’s analysis, not a court statement.

The next hearing is on 25 November

The court has scheduled a follow-up session for Wednesday, 25 November 2026, to hear further testimony from the Industry Ministry, BPOM, the National Police and e-cigarette associations.

No ruling date has been set in the material available. For now the control rules in Law 17/2023 remain the framework in force, and the ban sought by the petitioners is a request before the court, not an enacted measure.

Questions readers ask

Has Indonesia banned e-cigarettes?

No. A petition in Constitutional Court case No. 363/PUU-XXIV/2026 asks the court to prohibit production, imports, distribution and use of e-cigarettes. The court is still hearing evidence, with a session set for 25 November 2026, and has not ruled.

What does the police circular from 30 October 2026 cover?

National Police Chief circular SE/9/X/2026 bans e-cigarette use by all police personnel, both inside and outside the workplace, according to the government's testimony to the court. It applies to police staff, not the general public.

Share

Sources

18+ only. This site is for adult readers and provides news and information only. It is not medical, legal or purchase advice. Nicotine is addictive. Always check the official text of any regulation in your market. Health Information

VapeBrief Policy Desk

A shared VapeBrief publication label for policy coverage, not a named person or a claim about team size, credentials or legal expertise.

About this byline →

Daily Brief newsletter

A concise email at 08:00 U.S. Eastern time each day, with links to the previous day’s published briefs.

Topics of interest

Active immediately, no confirmation click needed. Every email includes an unsubscribe link. See our Privacy Policy.