Indonesia MPs press to slow total vape ban over jobs
Indonesia's Commission III MPs asked the government to review a proposed total e-cigarette ban with unions, industry and the BNN, arguing a blanket prohibition threatens the legal sector and its workers. No ban has been decided or scheduled.
Key points
- Commission III DPR members asked on 17 November 2026 for a full review of a total vape ban before any decision.
- Andi Amar Ma'ruf Sulaiman wants the BNN, associations, practitioners and business owners included in drafting the rules.
- Rizki Faisal named law, economy, social effects, consumer protection and government supervision as the tests a ban must pass.
- No draft regulation, vote or effective date for a total ban appears in either report.
On this page
- Commission III wants the BNN, trade bodies and vape businesses in the room
- Rizki Faisal lists five tests before any ban
- No timeline, no bill and no confirmed prohibition
- Legal manufacturers and exporters face a policy risk without a deadline
- What comes next depends on a review with no scheduled date
- Questions readers ask
Two Commission III members of Indonesia’s DPR asked the government on 17 November 2026 to review a proposed total e-cigarette ban across the economy, jobs and enforcement before adopting it.
The push back does not stop a ban. Both politicians, Andi Amar Ma’ruf Sulaiman and Golkar’s Rizki Faisal, framed their remarks as input into a policy that is still being drafted, not as a rejection of restrictions.
Commission III wants the BNN, trade bodies and vape businesses in the room
Andi Amar said the problems behind the proposal sit outside health alone, and that rules drawn up by government and law enforcement without wider input will miss the field conditions the legal industry works in.
He named the National Narcotics Agency (BNN), community groups, practitioners, associations and business owners as participants in what he called a healthy discussion to integrate the regulation.
He also offered a direct hearing to industry practitioners, arguing that manufacturers and distributors know products, distribution and device technology well enough to help officials separate legal goods from illegal devices misused for narcotics.
Rizki Faisal lists five tests before any ban
The Golkar member said a total prohibition cannot rest on a single viewpoint and set out the criteria he wants weighed: law, the economy, social effects, consumer protection and how effectively the government can supervise the market.
He said disagreement between supporters of a full ban and those who prefer tighter regulation should feed the policy drafting rather than be suppressed, and that the final rules must protect young people and public health while giving businesses legal certainty.
No timeline, no bill and no confirmed prohibition
Neither account gives a date for a decision, a draft regulation number, a parliamentary vote or an effective date, and neither states that a total ban has been formally proposed in a text the DPR is debating.
The scale of the employment impact is also unsupported: the reporting refers to hundreds of thousands of workers and to mass economic effects, but publishes no workforce figure, industry output number or revenue estimate behind either description.
Waspada.id carries the same statements from Andi Amar and Rizki Faisal as the Medan report. Neither account adds facts the other lacks on dates or legal status.
Legal manufacturers and exporters face a policy risk without a deadline
Analysis: for Indonesian manufacturers, exporters and their Shenzhen suppliers, the practical change is that the ban debate now has an explicit industry-consultation channel, so trade associations have a route to submit product, distribution and enforcement data before any text is fixed.
Nothing in the reporting changes registration, labelling or shipment requirements now, and no compliance deadline exists to plan around.
| Item | Status as reported | Date |
|---|---|---|
| Total e-cigarette ban | Under discussion; no decision, draft number or vote reported | None stated |
| Scope of consultation sought | BNN, community, practitioners, associations, businesses | 17 November 2026 |
| Criteria named by Rizki Faisal | Law, economy, social, consumer protection, supervision | 17 November 2026 |
| Effective date | Not stated | — |
What comes next depends on a review with no scheduled date
The next visible step is the cross-sector discussion Andi Amar proposed, which has no announced date, venue or participant list. Whether the government opens a formal consultation, publishes a draft or keeps the ban as a proposal is not reported, so distributors should treat the ban as unlegislated until a text appears.
Questions readers ask
Has Indonesia banned vapes completely?
No. As of 17 November 2026 the total ban is described only as a proposal under discussion, and Commission III members asked for a wider review. Neither report cites an enacted law, a draft number or an effective date.
Who did the MPs want involved in the review?
Andi Amar Ma'ruf Sulaiman named the National Narcotics Agency (BNN), community groups, practitioners, associations and vape business owners. Rizki Faisal said the debate should weigh law, economy, social effects, consumer protection and supervision.
Sources
18+ only. This site is for adult readers and provides news and information only. It is not medical, legal or purchase advice. Nicotine is addictive. Always check the official text of any regulation in your market. Health Information



