UK court clears driver after vape screen mistaken for phone
Brighton magistrates cleared Jodie Adams of using a phone while driving after she demonstrated in the witness box how her vape's screen lights up. She had already admitted driving without insurance and was fined.
Key points
- Magistrates at Brighton found Jodie Adams not guilty of using a mobile phone while driving after she demonstrated her vape's screen in the witness box.
- PC Oakley told the court he saw Adams typing on a phone in a blue Seat near the Cuilfail tunnel on 5 May, but accepted the device she showed him was not a phone.
- Adams had already pleaded guilty to driving without insurance and was fined £120, with a £49 surcharge and £85 in costs.
- PC Couchie, who stopped Adams, works in Sussex Police's Fatal Five Unit, set up earlier this year to target causes of road deaths including phone distraction.
On this page
- Adams was stopped near the Cuilfail tunnel on 5 May
- The defence turned on whether a screen and a button make a phone
- Magistrates fined Adams for the insurance offence she had admitted
- Screen-equipped devices complicate roadside identification
- What the ruling changes for sellers and drivers
- No further step is scheduled in this case
- Questions readers ask
Magistrates in Brighton found a 31-year-old driver not guilty of using a mobile phone while driving after she showed them the screen on her vape, which a police officer had taken for a phone.
Adams was stopped near the Cuilfail tunnel on 5 May
Jodie Adams, of Beacon Road in Crowborough, told Brighton Magistrates’ Court that she was driving towards Brighton on 5 May when police stopped her near the end of the Cuilfail tunnel by Malling Street roundabout in Lewes.
A plain-clothes road officer, PC Oakley, told the court he saw her holding a mobile phone in her right hand in a blue Seat and typing as she drove towards the A26. He said he could tell from the movement of her thumb and told the court he could confirm with certainty that it was a phone, though he could not be sure the screen was lit because many phones have privacy screens.
The defence turned on whether a screen and a button make a phone
Representing herself, Adams showed the officer her vape, which she said has a screen and a button, and asked whether he could be certain what he saw was a phone. PC Oakley accepted that the device was not a mobile phone and said he would have recognised the vape easily.
PC Couchie, positioned in high-visibility gear at the end of the tunnel with other officers, stopped Adams. Body-worn footage played in court recorded Adams saying she had not been typing and offering her phone for examination.
Adams told the court she was holding the vape in her right hand and tapping it, and that her phone was on the passenger seat connected to Apple CarPlay. The prosecuting barrister agent, Dominic Dudkowski, asked her to show how the vape’s screen works; with permission from the magistrates she took two puffs in the witness box and showed the screen lighting up with a battery percentage before switching off.
Magistrates fined Adams for the insurance offence she had admitted
The bench, led by Matthew Irish, acquitted Adams of using a mobile phone while driving.
| Outcome | Charge or penalty | Amount or result |
|---|---|---|
| Acquitted | Using a mobile phone while driving | Not guilty |
| Admitted earlier | Driving without insurance | Guilty plea |
| Fine | Insurance offence | £120 |
| Surcharge | Insurance offence | £49 |
| Court costs | Insurance offence | £85 |
Screen-equipped devices complicate roadside identification
The case turned on the appearance of a device that carries a display, a button and a battery indicator — features that overlap with a handset held in one hand. The officer’s evidence relied on the position of the thumb, not on what the screen showed.
PC Couchie works in Sussex Police’s “Fatal Five Unit”, which the force set up earlier this year to reduce deaths and serious injuries from five leading causes that include distraction by mobile phones, the court heard.
What the ruling changes for sellers and drivers
The acquittal settles one prosecution, not the legal position of any device. It does not create a rule that vaping at the wheel is permitted, and it does not change how police decide to stop a vehicle.
For manufacturers and distributors, the practical effect is narrower: the case shows that a device with an illuminated screen can be mistaken for a phone from outside a car, so packaging, manuals and retailer guidance that describe screen behaviour have a roadside context as well as a product one. Analysis: suppliers have no new compliance obligation from this verdict, but the technology mix now sold in the UK is the kind of detail that can end up in a prosecution file.
No further step is scheduled in this case
The bench delivered its verdict at trial and the penalties for the insurance offence were set in the same proceedings. A driver stopped in similar circumstances would still face a roadside decision by the officer, with any dispute left to a court.
Questions readers ask
Is vaping while driving illegal in the UK?
The court case reported here concerned a charge of using a mobile phone while driving, and the driver was acquitted because the device was a vape. Nothing in the source states a separate rule on vaping at the wheel.
What penalty did Jodie Adams receive?
She was fined £120 for driving without insurance, which she had admitted, plus a £49 surcharge and £85 in court costs.
Sources
18+ only. This site is for adult readers and provides news and information only. It is not medical, legal or purchase advice. Nicotine is addictive. Always check the official text of any regulation in your market. Health Information



